The Georgia Supreme Court has refused to strike down that state’s statute of repose in medical malpractice cases when challenged on equal protection grounds. Georgia has a five-year statue of repose in medical malpractice cases (Tennessee has a three-year statute of repose).
The case is Nichols v. Gross, S07A1027 ( Georgia S. C. Nov. 21, 2007). Read the opinion here.
An article in the Archives of Internal Medicine looked at closed malpractice claims to see what caused the errors made by medical trainees. A summary of the findings:
"Among 240 cases, errors in judgment (173 of 240 [72%]), teamwork breakdowns (167 of 240 [70%]), and lack of technical competence (139 of 240 [58%]) were the most prevalent contributing factors. Lack of supervision and handoff problems were most prevalent types of teamwork problems, and both were disproportionately more common among errors that involved trainees than those that did not (respectively, 54% vs 7% [P < .001] and 20% vs 12% [P = .009]). The most common task during which failures of technical competence occurred were diagnostic decision making and monitoring of the patient or situation. Trainee errors appeared more complex than nontrainee errors (mean of 3.8 contributing factors vs 2.5 [P < .001])." You can access the article here.
Thanks to the DC Metro Malpractice Blog for informing me about the article.
The Tennessee Supreme Court has ruled that an arbitration provision in a nursing home contract signed by a person who had a power of attorney to act on behalf of the resident is not void as against public policy. However, the court remanded the case to the trial court for a determniation of whether the inclusion of the provision was an unconscionable contract of adhesion.
Justice Holder wrote the opinion for the Court. Here is a summary of the holding:
"the agreement is governed by the Tennessee Uniform Arbitration Act and that the power of attorney authorized Daniel to sign the arbitration agreement on behalf of King. We also affirm the intermediate appellate court’s holding that the arbitration agreement is not unenforceable on the ground that a material term of the agreement is incapable of performance. We likewise affirm the Court of Appeals’ holding that the arbitration agreement does not violate federal law. We further hold that a pre-dispute arbitration agreement in a nursing-home contract is not per se invalid as against public policy. In addition, we affirm the intermediate appellate court’s holding that the agreement is not unenforceable on the ground that requiring King to sign an arbitration agreement breached a purported fiduciary duty owed to King by the defendants. We vacate, however, the Court of Appeals’ judgment insofar as it holds that the arbitration agreement is not an unconscionable contract of adhesion, and we remand for further proceedings on that issue. In light of our remand for further proceedings on the unconscionability issue, we also vacate the intermediate appellate court’s instruction to the trial court to enter an order compelling arbitration."
The Tennessee Supreme Court has granted permission to appeal in two cases that address the issue of apparent agency. In both cases plainitffs seek to impose liability on a hospital for the acts of a doctor. The cases have been consolidated for appeal.
One case is DeWald v. HCA Heatlh Services of Tennessee, No. M2006-02369-COA-R9-CV (Tenn. Ct. App. June 12, 2007);. This case involves an ER physician. Read the opinion here.
The other case is Boren v. Weeks, No. M2007-00628-COA-R0-CV (Tenn. Ct. App. June 12, 2007). This case also involves an ER physician. Read the opinion here.
The LA Times makes an extraordinary effort here to tell the story of the death of a woman in a local hospital – and how it could have been prevented.
Medicare is no longer going to pay hospitals from costs arising from "preventable errors" and "serious preventable events."
What are preventable errors? The Washington Post story on the subject says this: "bedsores, or pressure ulcers; injuries caused by falls; and infections resulting from the prolonged use of catheters in blood vessels or the bladder."
Serious preventable events? They are events that should not occur during a hospital stay such as "leaving a sponge or other object in a patient during surgery and providing a patient with incompatible blood or blood products."
From a full-page ad in yesterday’s Knoxville’s Sunday News Sentinel:
Last year, Covenant Health hospitals saved the lives of 752 people who would not have lived at average hospitals.
According to U.S. government data, quality care makes a life-saving difference for patients at Covenant Health hospitals. By being far better than national averages, we help more patients survive – 753 more than the national norms last year alone.
The Tennessee Attorney General’s Office has just released on opinion on the issue of the ability of non-physician health care professionals to own and operate a medical practice and to employee physicians. Here are the two specific issues addressed:
"1. Considering the provisions of Tenn. Code Ann. §§ 63-6-204(b), 68-11-205(a), or any other law of this state, is it lawful for a certified nurse practitioner, registered nurse, advanced practice nurse, licensed practical nurse or physician assistant to own and operate a professional practice wherein medical services are provided?
2. Considering the provisions of Tenn. Code Ann. § 63-6-204(c) or any other law of this state, is it lawful for a physician to be an employee of, or an independent contractor to, a certified nurse practitioner, registered nurse, advanced practice nurse, licensed practical nurse or physician assistant for the sole purpose of providing the supervision, responsibility and control required by Tenn. Code Ann. § 63-6-204(b) for medical services being provided by those licensed allied health care providers at their practice sites? For purposes of this question, we assume that the physician, if he or she actively practices clinical medicine at all, does so primarily (if not exclusively) at some office or location other than at the referenced practice sites."
And here is the summary of the answers to those questions:
How much transparency should there be in health care? In commerce in general?
Senator Grassley wants transparency in medicine – he has introduced legislation that is designed to require drug companies to disclose what they pay doctors. Read about the legislation in this article from the New York Times. The article says that Grassley "cited as an example the case of a prominent child psychiatrist, who he said made $180,000 over just two years from the maker of an antipsychotic drug now widely prescribed for children."
This is interesting, too: "Mr. Grassley said that he had asked how much the child psychiatrist, Dr. Melissa DelBello at the University of Cincinnati, made from AstraZeneca, the London-based drug giant that manufactures the antipsychotic Seroquel. Dr. DelBello’s studies of Seroquel in children have helped to fuel the widespread pediatric use of antipsychotic medicines. Those studies were inconclusive, but she has described them as demonstrating that Seroquel is effective in some children. Asked in a past newspaper interview how much she was paid by AstraZeneca to help market Seroquel, she had said, “Trust me, I don’t make very much.” Mr. Grassley said this week that her disclosure forms at the University of Cincinnati show she received $100,000 from AstraZeneca in 2003 and $80,000 in 2004. Dr. DelBello consults for seven other drug makers as well. She did not respond to requests for comment this week. "
Charlie Weis, the head coach of the Notre Dame football team, lost the medical malpractice case he filed in Massachusetts.
The lawsuit arose out of gastric bypass surgery Weis had in June of 2002. According to this article posted on www.boston.com, "Weis, 51, who became ill after the operation, alleged that the surgeons were negligent for letting him bleed internally for 30 hours before they started a second surgery to respond to the complication. He testified he still has numbness and pain in his feet and had to use a motorized cart shortly after the operation."
Day on Torts