The case: Robinson v. LeCorps, 83 S.W.3d 718 (Tenn. 2002). Author: Justice E. Riley Anderson Why it is a Blue Chipper: Robinson made it crystal clear that a standard of care expert in a medical malpractice case may not base that testimony on a national standard of care and that…
Articles Posted in Medical Negligence
New Tennessee Supreme Court Opinion on “Foreign Object” Exception to Medical Malpractice Statute of Repose
The Supreme Court of Tennessee issued an important ruling on the “foreign object” exception to the medical malpractice statute of repose and statute of limitations. The case is Chambers v. Semmer, M.D., and deals with what exactly constitutes a foreign object. The plaintiff’s theory in the case is that a…
Medical Negligence
I apologize for the lack of a post Friday and Saturday. Friday morning I was in North Carolina and did not have access to a computer. By the time I made it to the office I had back-to-back conference calls or appointments until 4:15 and just decided to wait until…
Breaking News: Supreme Court Bars Ex Parte Talks with Plaintiff’s Doctors
The Supreme Court just issued its opinion in Alsip et al v. Johnson City Medical Center et al. More information on the opinion, holding that defense counsel may not participate in ex parte communications with a plaintiff’s non–party treating physicians, is available over at our firm’s medical malpractice blog. I…
Summary Summary Judgment
Judge Koch and the Court of Appeals for the Middle Section have ruled that a summary judgment in favor of a doctor in a medical malpractice case must be reversed because the plaintiff was not given adequate time to marshal the facts necessary to respond to it and submit an…
New Book on Patient Safety Standards
The Joint Commission has released the Fourth Edition of its book “Patient Safety Essentials for Health Care.” The blurb: “This book is the complete guide to the Joint Commission’s safety standards for ambulatory care, behavioral health care, critical access hospital, home care, hospital, and long term care organizations. It includes…
Displinary History of Surgeon Not Admissible at Trial
The Nebraska Supreme Court has ruled that plaintiffs could not argue that a surgeon should have disclosed his displinary history unless there was proof that the standard of care required disclosure. The Court held that plaintiffs “never established that the standard of care required such disclosures. Rather, they ask us…
More from Steven
Steven and I have been having a discussion – it started here. Here is his latest missive: “My mistake, I did not mean to state that this particular lawyer(s) was sleazy, but that the trial bar in general is sleazy. I will admit that there must be some decent trial…
Amounts of Settlement Not Discoverable
The Arizona Court of Appeals has ruled that the amounts of settlements made by doctor in other cases are not discoverable in another medical malpractice action against him. The case is Miller v. Kelly; it is reported at 130 P.3d 982 (Ariz. App. 2006). The Court held that “the amount…
Wrong Site Surgeries
Go to the Tennessee Medical Malpractice Law Blog for a post on wrong site surgeries.