North Carolina has come into the late 20th century by adopting a legal citation system that makes sense for the lawyers of today – and the public. The state Supreme Court adopted a new format for case citations, the reference that tells the public how to find a specific court…
Day on Torts
Motion for Substitution Needed After Death of Plaintiff
Where a plaintiff filed a Tennessee health care liability (medical malpractice) action and died of unrelated causes while the suit was pending, the cause of action did not automatically pass to his wife. Instead, the suit was “eligible to be revived” and a motion for substitution of party should have…
Fair Report Privilege Did Not Apply to Private Conversation in Defamation Case
The Tennessee Supreme Court recently affirmed that the fair report privilege does not apply to “a nonpublic, one-on-one conversation between a newspaper reporter and a detective of the county sheriff’s department, who also served as the public information officer for the sheriff’s department.” In Burke v. Sparta Newspapers, Inc., No.…
Car Accident Suit Against Deceased Defendant Dismissed as Untimely
Where a tortfeasor died before suit was filed and “no personal representive was appointed for the deceased tortfeasor and more than a year had elapsed following the accrual of the plaintiff’s cause of action,” dismissal of the Tennessee personal injury suit was affirmed. In Khah v. Capley, No. M2018-02189-COA-R3-CV…
Self-Driving Truck Goes Cross Country
An autonomous tractor-trailer recently completed a cross-country trip carrying a load of butter. Although autonomous truck and car technology is not yet for prime time, the tests continue. The impact on the trucking industry will be significant. Personal costs are one-third of the marginal cost of running a truck, even…
Failure to Name Correct Defendant Fatal to Claim
Where plaintiff brought suit against a trucking company based on injuries he received while operating a forklift inside a trailer at the distribution center at which he was employed, summary judgment was appropriate where the defendant trucking company produced records showing that the truck plaintiff was injured in did not…
Injuried Party Need Not Be Included in Declaratory Judgment Action Between Defendant and Defendant’s Insurer
An injured person who had sued an insured but did not yet have a judgment against the insured was not an indispensable party in a declaratory action between the insurance company and the insured regarding coverage of the accident. In Tennessee Farmers Mutual Insurance Company v. DeBruce, No. E2017-02078-SC-R11-CV (Tenn.…
Utilities Commission Had No Jurisdiction Over Negligence Suit
When a plaintiff brought a negligence action against two public utility companies for damages allegedly done to her real property when the gas was turned off and waters pipes subsequently froze and burst, the trial court erred by holding that the Tennessee Public Utility Commission (TPUC) had exclusive jurisdiction of…
Law Firms Made to Pay for Failure to Honor Medicare Subrogation
Medicare makes conditional payments to health care providers on behalf of its beneficiaries who are injured or killed and later assert personal injury or wrongful death claims. Federal law requires that the monies advanced by Medicare be paid back subject to a formula that allows for the reduction of the…
Defamation Claim Asserted by Public Figure
To defeat summary judgment on a defamation claim, a public figure needed to “produce clear and convincing evidence of actual malice at the summary judgment stage.” In Elsten v. Coker, No. M2019-00034-COA-R3-CV (Tenn. Ct. App. Oct. 4, 2019), plaintiff and defendant were both running for mayor of Hendersonville. Before the…